• Skip to main content

CentreForMedicalHumanities.org

  • Home
  • Telehealth Analysis
  • Research Translations
  • Evidence Reviews
  • Blog
  • About

Distant Voices, Still Lives: Revealing the Experience of Illness through the Narratives of Others Past and Present – Dr Claire McKechnie (Lecture, Edinburgh, 3 April 2013)

posted on March 15, 2025

Research Summary: Narratives of Illness and Grief across 150 Years

Topic: Medical Humanities lecture examining illness narratives from 1806–2004
Key Focus Areas: Emily Gosse (1806–1857), Joy Davidman (1915–1960), Susan Sontag (1933–2004)
Primary Sources Examined: Narratives by Emily's husband and son; C. S. Lewis's grief account of Joy Davidman; David Reiff's Swimming in a Sea of Death
Speaker & Affiliation: Dr Claire McKechnie, Medical Humanities Research, University of Edinburgh
Event Details: 3 April 2013, 5:30–6:30 pm, Jordanburn Lecture Theatre, Royal Edinburgh Hospital; free but ticketed
Project Context: Part of “Ever Present Past” initiative marking the Royal Edinburgh Hospital's bicentenary year
Scholarly Perspective: Reveals how third-party narratives illuminate the subjective experience of illness, grief, and medical treatment across historical periods

Distant Voices, Still Lives: Revealing the Experience of Illness through the Narratives of Others Past and Present
Wed 3rd April 5.30pm – 6.30pm
Jordanburn lecture theatre, Kennedy Tower, Royal Edinburgh Hospital
Free but ticketed. Booking essential.

A talk which reveals the experience of illness through the narratives of others past and present. Dr Claire McKechnie, Medical Humanities Research, University of Edinburgh, will explore narratives of grief from the past 150 years.

She will focus on three individuals, Emily Gosse 1806-1857, Joy Davidman 1915-1960 and Susan Sontag 1933-2004. Claire will reveal the story of Dr Jesse Weldon Fell and his treatment of Emily Gosse in the mid 1850s through the narratives of Emily’s husband and son.

She will then turn her attention to the famous grief narrative of C. S. Lewis about his wife Joy Davidman’s decline and death. Finally she will discuss the significance of the story of Susan Sontag’s final illness, as narrated by her son David Reiff, Swimming in a Sea of Death.

The talk is part of ‘Ever Present Past’ project at the Royal Edinburgh Hospital developed and coordinated by Artlink. The project explores the history of the Hospital through a series of talks, events and workshops and artist placements throughout 2013 – the Hospital’s bi-centenary year.

To Book go to www.artlinkedinburgh.co.uk, email or phone 0131 229 3555.

Filed Under: Seminar

CentreForMedicalHumanities.org is an independent health evidence publication. This site is not a medical practice, healthcare provider, academic institution, or research organization. Nothing on this site constitutes medical advice. Consult a qualified healthcare provider before making decisions about supplements, medications, or health interventions. This website is not affiliated with Durham University, the Institute for Medical Humanities, or any academic or medical institution. The domain name reflects previous ownership history and does not indicate institutional affiliation, academic authority, or endorsement. The Durham Institute for Medical Humanities is an active research institute at Durham University — visit their official page for information about their programs and research. Some content on this site contains affiliate links. Purchases made through these links may generate a commission for this publication at no cost to the reader. See our Evidence Standards page for full disclosure details. Content produced by the CMH Evidence Review editorial team. © 2026 CentreForMedicalHumanities.org. All rights reserved. | About | Our Evidence Standards | Non-Affiliation Notice | Privacy Policy